Lambert House on Chestnut Street is designated a Local Landmark

SITUATION IN 2017 - 2018

The Lambert House at 128 Chestnut Street was at risk of demolition in 2017. It is one of the few antebellum houses remaining on West Newton Hill.  The first owner, Rev Henry Lambert, was an active abolitionist and leader in civil service reform. The fountain and sculpture by Anne Whitney,  on the island garden at the intersection of Chestnut and Highland Streets, is in memory of his wife, Catherine Wigglesworth Porter Lambert. (See more background under the "Learn" tab.)

City Council members from Ward 3 requested that the Newton Historical Commission consider Local Landmark status for this house in April 2018. See May 11 Boston Globe article here.  The seller's representatives explained that there were plans to sell to a developer who would demolish the house and subdivide the lot. 

The Newton Historical Commission accepted a request for a continuance at its May meeting. At the June 28, 2018, meeting, the NHC voted to name the house a Local Landmark. See July 5, 2018, Boston Globe article here.

UPDATE 2022

The historic house, which had originally been at the center of the lot, was subsequently moved forward towards Chestnut Street, in order to make room for a subdivision with a second lot behind it. A large new home was constructed facing Westfield Road. Both lots remain under the oversight of the Newton Historical Commission. Although substantially renovated and altered, the Lambert House is still standing.

Newton holds Public Hearing for local historic district (LHD); with neighborhood views mixed, proposal does not proceed

The first part of the public hearing on the LHD for West Newton Hill took place on June 12th, 2017, in City Hall, moderated by City Council member Ted Hess-Mahan and with other members of the Zoning and Planning committee of the City Council, the Planning Board, and the Newton Historical Commission present.  The slide presentation shared by the WNH preservation team is available by clicking the links below. Here is a link to notes for the presentation.  A group of neighbors opposed to introducing a LHD also presented their viewpoints at the public hearing.

The City Planning Department then sent out a mail-in survey in 2017 to homeowners living within the proposed district. People were invited to express their views in writing to the Planning Department,  the Zoning and Planning Committee of the City Council and the Newton Historical Commission.

The Presentation given by the West Newton Preservation Initiative is attached below.

Presentation:

Massachusetts Historical Commission wholeheartedly supports proposed Local Historic District for West Newton Hill

In its monthly meeting on March 8th, the state historical commission voted to receive the preliminary report about a proposed West Newton Hill local historic district, and to encourage the City of Newton to establish the district. The report can be viewed on this website. The MHC issued an advisory opinion which acknowledges the historical and architectural significance of the neighborhood. 

 

Community invited to read report on WNH history and architecture

The research requested by the Newton Historical Commission in June 2016 was completed in early January by a team of volunteers, following the guidelines provided by the Massachusetts Historical Commission. Community members are encouraged to take a look at the West Newton Hill Local Historic District, Preliminary Study Report . The report contains historical information and photographs of examples the distinctive architecture in the neighborhood and also background on how and why West Newton Hill developed the way that it has.

Panel on Preservation Strategies

The City Planning Department hosted a panel called ‘Tools & Strategies  for Preservation in Newton’ on October 13th at Newton Free Library.  A video of the presentations can be viewed here.

The speakers included: Sally Zimmerman, Senior Planning of Preservation Services at Historic New England; Christopher Skelly, Director of Local Government Programs at Massachusetts Historical Commision; Katy Hax Holmes, Senior Planner for Newton Historical Commission; and James Freas, Deputy Director of Planning and Development in Newton.

http://www.newtonma.gov/gov/planning/histpres/default.asp

 

Demolition in 2016 of Historic Home on Valentine Street

The 1917 home shown in the photo below was demolished today after the developer waited out the year long delay required by the Newton Historical Commission. See Boston Globe article here by Allison Pohle, "Teardowns spur West Newton Hill to consider historic district."

The realtor offering the house at 174 Valentine Street described it in the listing as "impeccably maintained" and "boasting artisan quality craftsmanship".  Neighbors have been monitoring the felling of mature trees on the lot which fronts on both Valentine and Bigelow Road,  and many gathered to watch the ultimate reduction of the home to a pile of rubble by mid-day today, as shown on the videos linked below.

Demolitions have been on the rise on West Newton Hill and in other parts in Newton, as reported in depth by Jonathan Dame in this July 2016 Newton TAB article, "Newton's big teardown:As demolitions increase, some areas impacted more than others."

These short video clips were taken on September 16th.

Video courtesy of Melissa Chaikof

Video courtesy of Kim Maire

Video courtesy of Deborah Costolloe of Catchlight Painting

                        Photo courtesy of Nancy Morrison taken on Sept 14th prior to demolition: